You spent an evening comparing photos to decide whether you are 4B or 4C. You landed on an answer, bought the product line the videos recommend for your number, and followed the application order exactly as written. The hair at your nape came out well, the hair at the front puffed up, and the section at the back of your crown still has that straw-like look that neither of the other two has.
The obvious conclusion is that you got the number wrong. That you are actually 4C and not 4B, or the other way round. So comes the second round of videos, the second product line, and the same uneven result.
The problem is not that you picked the wrong letter. It is that the letter does not contain the information you were looking for in it.
Where the number comes from
The 1 to 4 scale with the A, B and C letters was born in the beauty industry in the 1990s, in a system created by a hairdresser to organise conversations with clients and, later, to organise shelves. The letter subdivisions spread online, in forums and natural hair content sites, and grew finer and finer as people argued about the differences between them.
At no point was it a measurement method. There is no device that says “4B”, there is no numerical cut-off point between 4B and 4C, and two people looking at the same lock of hair disagree often. It is vocabulary, and vocabulary has value. It just is not data.
For comparison: there is scientific literature that classifies hair curvature using measured parameters rather than photos. A method published by cosmetic industry researchers in 2007 works with eight types defined by four objective measurements, among them the diameter of the curve the strand describes, the number of waves and the number of twists along its length. That kind of scale exists because, for research purposes, “coily” and “very coily” do not do the job.
The point is that neither the good scale nor the popular one tells you what happens when you put cream on your hair.
One head does not have one number
This is the part the classification hides, and it is the most practical of all.
The follicle determines the curl pattern of the strand through its own shape: a more curved follicle with asymmetric growth produces a more tightly coiled strand with a flatter cross-section. And the follicles on one head are not identical to each other. They vary by region, and that is the rule, not the exception.
On most coily heads at least two distinct curl patterns show up, often three: the hairline and the temples with finer strands and a different pattern, the crown with the tightest pattern and usually the driest stretch, the nape with strands that are frequently softer and a looser pattern.
Add to that the history. If there has been relaxing, colouring, bleaching or years of flat ironing, the root is in one condition and the length is in another, on the same strand. The band where new chemistry met old chemistry is a third condition.
So when you choose “the 4C routine”, you are choosing a routine for the stretch of hair you used as your reference, and applying it to four or five different situations.
What the number does not tell you, and what actually decides the routine
Curl pattern is one variable among several. It basically determines shape and how much shrinkage you see: on tightly coiled hair, dry hair can show less than half its real length, and that is why the ruler in the mirror lies to you.
What decides how hair behaves with water and product is a different list.
| Variable | What it is | How you see it | What it decides |
|---|---|---|---|
| Curl pattern | The shape of the curve the strand describes | By eye, with bias | Shrinkage, volume, how much definition is possible |
| Porosity | Cuticle integrity, how many scales are lifted and where | Under magnification, and by how fast it wets and dries | How much water gets in, how long product lasts, whether a humectant helps or hurts |
| Strand thickness | Fibre diameter, in the micrometre range (thousandths of a millimetre) | Under magnification, or compared against sewing thread | How much weight a strand takes before it drops, whether a heavy cream shapes the curl or flattens it |
| Density | How many strands per square centimetre of scalp | Counting under magnification | Volume, how much product the whole head needs, how it is sectioned |
| Elasticity | How far a strand stretches when wet and springs back without snapping | A controlled tension test | Whether rebuilding treatment fits, whether heat fits, whether chemistry fits |
Two people with the same curl pattern and opposite porosities need different routines. Two people with the same porosity and opposite strand thicknesses do too. And the letter is the same in all four cases.
This is where the routine you find online fails: it was built around the axis that tells you the least.
The glass of water test does not measure porosity
It is worth naming the test that circulates most, because it gets in the way of the decision.
Pull out a strand, drop it in a glass and watch whether it sinks. The idea is that a porous strand absorbs water, becomes denser and goes down. The trouble is that what decides whether it floats there is surface tension and air trapped on the surface of the strand, plus any residue of product, silicone or oil still on it. A clean strand and a strand with yesterday’s leave-in behave differently at the same porosity. And one strand does not represent the whole head, precisely because the head has distinct regions.
More useful observations, which you can make without equipment:
How long your hair takes to soak through under the shower. If the water is slow to get in and runs off the surface, the cuticle is closed and sealed. If it soaks in seconds, the cuticle is open.
How long it takes to dry, comparing the regions. The area that dries first and goes back to feeling rough is the most porous one, and it is where product disappears soonest.
If a strand stretches a lot when wet and does not spring back, or snaps under very little force, that is not a question of curl pattern or styling. It is integrity, and it changes the whole plan.
So what is the classification good for
It is good for three things, and they are good things.
First, for talking. Saying “4C at the crown and 4A at the nape” delivers more information in six words than a long description does, and it works for giving a reference point during an appointment.
Second, for calibrating shrinkage expectations. Anyone with a very tight curl pattern needs to know, before cutting, that visible length is not real length, and the cut has to be planned both dry and wet.
Third, for guiding handling technique. A tighter curl pattern has more twist points per centimetre, and a twist point is where a strand breaks under friction. That defines how you detangle, not which cream you buy.
What the classification is not good for is being a purchasing criterion. Products are chosen by porosity, thickness and chemical history. The letter comes in afterwards, in the technique.
When it is not curl pattern, it is an appointment with a doctor
None of the above applies to the scalp. Itching that does not go away, flaking that comes back within days, redness, pain to the touch, circular bald patches, a receding front hairline or receding temple edges: that is a case for a dermatologist, preferably before any salon protocol. Receding edges in anyone who wears tight updos or braids under tension deserves prompt attention, because there is a point at which the follicle stops responding.
Hair therapy works alongside a medical diagnosis, never in place of one.
If you would like to talk about your case
In the service for curly and coily hair at Nelblack, in Tatuapé, in the East Zone of São Paulo, the hair is read region by region before any recommendation, because that is exactly what classifying by number does not solve: curl pattern, porosity, thickness and chemical history change from one point of the head to another, and the routine has to follow that difference.
If your question involves breakage, shrinkage that has got worse, the scalp or shedding, there is the trichoscope hair assessment (a lit magnifying lens, for looking at strand and scalp up close). It costs R$200 in Brazilian reais, credited in full towards the protocol if you go ahead with it, and you follow the assessment on the screen together with the professional. We measure again, at the same points, during or at the last session and compare with the image from the first day. At no extra cost.
Nelma Faleiro is a specialist in Cosmetic Trichology, spent ten years as a university lecturer and researches how coily hair behaves when it goes through chemical processes. We are open Tuesday to Saturday, 9am to 6pm, by appointment, and Tuesday is the day reserved for scalp therapy. We can see you in English, which helps if you are living in São Paulo or just passing through: the salon is in the Carrão and Tatuapé metro area, a straightforward trip on the red line.