You set Saturday morning aside for it. You washed, parted the hair into thin sections, worked cream and gel through strand by strand, waited for it to dry. The result was good enough to photograph. On Wednesday, washing in a hurry before work, you scrunched it with your hands in four minutes and walked out with exactly the hair you had before you learned any technique.
The automatic reading is that you have not mastered the technique. That more practice would solve it, or that the right product would shorten the process.
That is not it. Shingling, finger coiling and scrunching are not three skill levels on the same scale. They are three different decisions about how big each clump of hair is, and each one charges a different amount of time, in a currency you pay every week.
What the three techniques are competing over is clump size
A defined curl, physically speaking, is a clump: a group of strands stuck to one another, held together by a thin film that forms as the water in the product evaporates and the polymers settle on the surface. Carbomer, xanthan gum, gelatine and fixative resins all do that job.
As long as the strand is holding water, it is pliable. The fibre absorbs close to a third of its own weight in water, swells and accepts a shape. When the water leaves, the shape locks.
Which means the technique does not create curl. Curl comes from the follicle, and no hand movement changes that. What the technique decides is something else: how many strands go into each clump, whether the clumps are similar in size to one another, and how long your hair spends wet and being handled.
The three, described by what the hands actually do
Raking and scrunching (the “traditional” method): product distributed through all of the hair with open hands, then compression from the ends upwards, pushing the length towards the scalp. The clumps form on their own, by the natural grouping of wet strands. Mixed sizes, irregular result by design.
**Shingling, or ribboning (fitagem in Brazilian salons):** the hair is parted into thin sections and the product is spread down each one by sliding it between two fingers, from root to tip, until the strand is smooth and loaded. The clump comes out elongated, uniform, with less volume. It is the technique that stretches apparent length the most.
**Finger coiling (dedoliss here, from dedo, finger):** each section is wound around a finger, in a spiral. The clump comes out cylindrical, at a diameter you chose. On very tight curl patterns, the spiral your finger makes tends to be tighter than the natural one, and the hair shrinks more than it would on its own.
The difference you came looking for, in one line: shingling lengthens and evens out, finger coiling draws and shrinks, scrunching keeps volume and accepts irregularity.
| Raking and scrunching | Shingling / ribboning | Finger coiling | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clump | mixed sizes, formed by the hair itself | thin, uniform, elongated | cylindrical, the diameter of your finger |
| Volume | keeps it or adds to it | reduces it a lot | reduces at the root, marks the length |
| Apparent length | your natural one | the longest of the three | the shortest of the three |
| Product it asks for | film former (gel, gelatine) | cream with slip, then gel on top | gel with good hold, and more of it |
| Drying | the fastest | long, the hair is loaded | the longest |
| A single frizzy strand shows | barely, volume hides it | a lot, any loose strand breaks the pattern | a lot, between one spiral and the next |
| Repeatable on a weekday | yes | rarely | almost never |
The arithmetic the twenty-minute video leaves out
Do the sums in your head, literally. Shingling done properly works sections one to two centimetres wide, less than an inch. A dense head of hair, parted at that thickness, gives you somewhere between forty and eighty sections. If each section takes thirty to sixty seconds between parting, applying and sliding, you land on twenty to eighty minutes of application alone.
Washing, conditioning and drying sit outside that count.
The twenty-minute video exists because it was filmed on one part of the head, or on shorter hair, or trimmed in the edit. There is no dishonesty in that, only framing. The problem appears when you use the framing as a benchmark for how long your own process should take, conclude that you are slow, and give up.
Finger coiling follows the same logic with one aggravating factor: the spiral has to be wound and then left alone until it is completely dry, because breaking it up before the water leaves undoes the shape you just made. Air drying dense hair loaded with gel is measured in hours, not minutes.
The cost that never shows up on the clock: time spent wet
Here is the argument that changes the decision for some readers.
Wet fibre is mechanically more fragile than dry fibre. It stretches much further before it snaps and springs back less, because water temporarily undoes the hydrogen bonds, the weak keratin links responsible for holding the shape. Ninety minutes of friction between your fingers, on soaking hair, is ninety minutes of handling in the most vulnerable state the fibre has.
On virgin, healthy hair that is tolerated well. On hair with a history of relaxer, colour or bleach, not necessarily. The cuticle is already more open, porosity is higher, and the strand comes out of the shingling session more worn than it went in.
There is a second point, a more serious one, with finger coiling: if the spiral is wound by pulling from the root, that repeated tension week after week on the same spot is a risk factor for traction alopecia, which is hair loss caused by mechanical tension on the follicle. Start the coil from the middle of the section, not at the root.
Why your definition does not last three days
A uniform clump is beautiful and fragile to maintain. The more alike the curls are to each other, the more visible the one strand that escaped its group after a night of friction on the pillow. The eye reads the set: one loose strand over a regular pattern jumps out, the same loose strand over irregular clumps disappears.
That is why shingling tends to give the best first day and the hardest second day of the three methods, while scrunching gives a less spectacular first day and a gentler decline until the next wash.
If your routine has three washes a week, the useful question is not which technique defines best. It is which technique you can stand to repeat six to twelve times a month.
The practical way out is to mix, not to choose
The decision does not have to be the same for the whole head. What tends to work in a real routine:
- Shingle only the face-framing pieces and the top, where the eye goes, and
scrunch the nape and the sides. You buy uniformity where it matters and save most of the time.
- Keep the long technique for the day that has room for it, and treat the other
washes with the four-minute method, guilt free.
- Keep the spray bottle within reach if you are shingling: the part you left for
last has already dried while you were working on the first, and product on dry hair does not form a continuous film.
- Change one variable at a time. Switching technique and product in the same
wash leaves you with no way of knowing which one worked.
When the subject is not definition
None of the above applies to the scalp. Itching that persists, flaking that comes back within a few days, redness, tenderness to the touch, shedding that has increased, patches with a defined shape: that is a case for a dermatologist, and preferably before any salon protocol.
In the same way, if the strand snaps when you stretch it gently, if the length is getting shorter without a cut, if there is exaggerated stretchiness when wet, the problem is the integrity of the fibre. A definition technique does not solve that, and insisting on one hides what needs to be looked at.
If you would like to talk about your case
Curl pattern, density and chemical history change which of these techniques is worth your time, and the videos have no way of knowing any of that about you. In the curly and coily hair appointment at Nelblack, in Tatuapé, the styling is done with you watching and with your own hands in your hair for part of the process, because the point is for the movement to be repeatable at home without giving up a whole Saturday morning.
If your question involves breakage, shedding or the scalp, there is the trichoscope hair assessment, R$200 (Brazilian reais), credited in full towards the protocol if you go ahead with it. You follow the trichoscopy images on screen together with the professional. We measure again during or at the last session and compare with the image from the first day, at no extra cost.
We are open Tuesday to Saturday, 9am to 6pm, by appointment, in Tatuapé, on the east side of São Paulo, near the Carrão and Tatuapé metro stations. Tuesday is the day reserved for scalp therapy. We can see you in English.